[Lovejesu42Os]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

My whole life I have lived on interpretations of the bible and make all my decisions based on it, however I enjoy the bands NOFX and The Misfits, are these bands dangerous to my christianity, and could they damage my children's minds as I play them all the time? Do you have a list of anti-christian bands so I can learn what to listen to? Also I have never heard of the Black Parade what should we what out for?

[Mr Eskimo Savage]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

I hate MCR, because they are the whiniest pieces of inbreed self-haters to ever survive their teens.

But, they can in no way be held responsible for people commiting suicide, and the black parade is not a religious thing.. its just a line from one of their sissy excuses for a song... God i wish for them nothing but pain and agony.

[MisterM]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

So what is the message of My Chemical Romance. Lets analyze.

A Kiss Before She Goes
-Drinking, corruption, loathing, sex with boys in the band, vampires, murder (blood and knife there) etc.

All I Want For Christmas Is You
-Quite ok, but nothing about Jesus even it is His Special Day

Art Is The Weapon
-Claiming to be better than God, don't care about Judgement day

Astro Zombies
-Black magic, Voodoo, raping, killing

Black Dragon Fighting Society
-Drinking and killing lust.

Black parade
-Worshiping female ghosts

Blood
-Drinking gallons of blood

Bulletproof Heart
-Running away from parents, shooting preachers, rejecting God.

Bury Me In Black
-Killing someone with a shotgun

And these where just names starting with A or B.

Sick! Perverted! Totally wacko, Satan worshiping stuff. You need to be totally insane to listen this.

YiC, M

[Cranky Old Man]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

I've listened to every single song they're written, and none of them have ever made me want to kill myself and many other people will agree with me.

Duh! Clearly most people will ignore the song's suggestion of suicide.

and I'm not trying to disrespect Hannah, but I think she killed herself because it was the emo stereotype, not because of My Chemical Romance who have expressed how wrong suicide is several times.

Did you notice they did that after they killed Hannah with their songs? Don't you find that to be just a little hypocritical? Of have they brainwashed you into approving whatever they do, no matter how horrible?

[HippieSlut]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

To Cranky Old Man,

I've listened to every single song they're written, and none of them have ever made me want to kill myself and many other people will agree with me.

and I'm not trying to disrespect Hannah, but I think she killed herself because it was the emo stereotype, not because of My Chemical Romance who have expressed how wrong suicide is several times.

AND

To Samuel Coleridge,

No, whoever goes around telling people to kill themselves (which My Chemical Romance DOES NOT DO ) are completely evil and sick.

[Cranky Old Man]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

They don't sing about suicide, they sing about living, and tell their fans not to hurt themselves or others.

You clearly never actually listened to one of their songs. Which is a good thing actually, but it would be wiser for you to stop talking about something you clearly know nothing about.

If they told their fans to go and kill themselves then there wouldn't be any left, they'd all be dead.

Of course not. Most people would just assume you are crazy if you ask them to kill themselves. Only a weak minded person, e.g. a girl named Hannah, would actually kill herself if a song suggested to do that.

[Samuel Coleridge]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

If they told their fans to go and kill themselves then there wouldn't be any left, they'd all be dead.

This is a bit frightening of a statement. You mean to say that you would kill yourself if MCR told you to?

[HippieSlut]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

So according to your "logic" if a band sings about people killing themselves and people start killing themselves, the band is not responsible?

Your "logic" would work great for crime bosses. Instead of commanding their subordinates to murder, steal and rape, all they have to do is sing the commands to their subordinates and suddenly they are all as innocent as a baby girl.

They don't sing about suicide, they sing about living, and tell their fans not to hurt themselves or others.

If they told their fans to go and kill themselves then there wouldn't be any left, they'd all be dead.

[Cranky Old Man]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

Yes, but it IS NOT their fault that Hannah committed suicide therefore they are not accountable for it. There isn't even any proof to back the story, and if you've ever read The Daily Mail then you'd know that it is a completely unreliable newspaper.

So according to your "logic" if a band sings about people killing themselves and people start killing themselves, the band is not responsible?

Your "logic" would work great for crime bosses. Instead of commanding their subordinates to murder, steal and rape, all they have to do is sing the commands to their subordinates and suddenly they are all as innocent as a baby girl.

[HippieSlut]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

So you finally agree they are accountable for their actions?

Yes, but it IS NOT their fault that Hannah committed suicide therefore they are not accountable for it. There isn't even any proof to back the story, and if you've ever read The Daily Mail then you'd know that it is a completely unreliable newspaper.

[Cranky Old Man]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

No, I did not say anything like that. You are twisting my words, and you have ignored the rest of what I said as well. If My Chemical Romance killed, raped or robbed a bank I wouldn't listen to them and I would make sure nobody else did, but that isn't the case. I'd do the same if it were any other band, singer, actress or role model.

So you finally agree they are accountable for their actions?

[HippieSlut]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

So once a few people form a band they are no longer accountable for their actions? So killing, raping and robbing banks is bad, unless you are in a band? Is that how it works for you?

No, I did not say anything like that. You are twisting my words, and you have ignored the rest of what I said as well. If My Chemical Romance killed, raped or robbed a bank I wouldn't listen to them and I would make sure nobody else did, but that isn't the case. I'd do the same if it were any other band, singer, actress or role model.

[Cranky Old Man]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

You can't blame a band because one young girl stereotyped herself and took it too far.

So once a few people form a band they are no longer accountable for their actions? So killing, raping and robbing banks is bad, unless you are in a band? Is that how it works for you?

[HippieSlut]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

You can't blame a band because one young girl stereotyped herself and took it too far.

I think this is absolute rubbish and you need to do more research, not just copy and paste a paragraph from The Daily Mail.

The band does not promote self harm. They do the exact opposite.

"You should never want to hurt yourself. You should love yourself."
"Suicide is a serious thing. And if you know anyone who is suicidal, you need to get them help. No one should be in pain. Everyone should love themselves. Like I love you all."
Both said by Gerard Way, and he's said much more stuff like this.

The fanbase finds My Chemical Romance really inspiring, and it's saved loads of lifes.

[Cranky Old Man]

Re: EMOS BELIEVE THEY GO TO THE 'BLACK PARADE' WHEN THEY DIE!

Let me ask you this: What rational parent would find their child cutting their wrist and only say ''don't do it again''?

What is the alternative, help them cut the other one?