[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Forget the whole "but good Christian women can protect themselves" thing and just answer the hypothetical question.

You don't get it, a good Christian woman is under the protection of God and of her father, brothers and church society.

If your daughter was raped by me, would you allow me to marry her once i paid you 50 shekels of silver worth? She would be damaged property after all.

You're really obsessed with this, do you think this is the only way that you are going to be capable of gaining a wife?

And if the rape was planned out, or the attacker/rapist knew how to disarm or attack an armed person i doubt an inexperienced woman simply in possession of a fire arms would be able to do anything about it.

Well IF I had a daughter, 1. she would not be inexperienced with firearms 2. She would almost always have a protection dog with her 3. She would not put herself into situations where you could get at her. Do you really think we allow our women to go out alone? To be unescorted on dates? No.

The law is quite clear, if you rape the woman in the city and she cries out, I have the Biblical and secular law on my side to kill you.

[zMuffinMan]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

It is a hypothetical question and you keep dodging it, if your daughter was successfully raped by me and unable to cry out or went unheard would you let me marry her once i paid the 50 shekels of silver worth to you?

[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

It is a hypothetical question and you keep dodging it, if your daughter was successfully raped by me and unable to cry out or went unheard would you let me marry her once i paid the 50 shekels of silver worth to you?

And I keep telling you that you would not hypothetically live.

[zMuffinMan]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

And I keep telling you that you would not hypothetically live.

Do you even know what hypothetical means?

Given those set of conditions i outlined would you or would you not let her marry me for the price of 50 shekels of silver worth? It is a hypothetical question which still remains unanswered.

[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Do you even know what hypothetical means?

Given those set of conditions i outlined would you or would you not let her marry me for the price of 50 shekels of silver worth? It is a hypothetical question which still remains unanswered.

Yes I know what hypothetical means, and I'm telling you that it is impossible so why should I bother answering?

If you hypothetically built a ladder to the moon, would you snack on the green cheese?

[zMuffinMan]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Yes I know what hypothetical means, and I'm telling you that it is impossible so why should I bother answering?

If you hypothetically built a ladder to the moon, would you snack on the green cheese?

Well obviously you actually don't know what hypothetical means because you keep saying it is impossible (even though it isn't impossible but that isn't important). Hypothetically speaking means to go under the assumption that it actually did happen without it actually happening in this context.

Now answer the question....

[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Well obviously you actually don't know what hypothetical means because you keep saying it is impossible (even though it isn't impossible but that isn't important). Hypothetically speaking means to go under the assumption that it actually did happen without it actually happening in this context.

Now answer the question....

Yet you didn't answer my hypothetical question because it's silly and impossible. That is the same reason I am not answering your question.

Read Deuteronomy 22 Your answer is in there.

[Pastor Ezekiel]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

It is a hypothetical question and you keep dodging it, if your daughter was successfully raped by me and unable to cry out or went unheard would you let me marry her once i paid the 50 shekels of silver worth to you?

What is this aggressive line of questioning about? Are you here trying to catch us in a contradiction of some kind, boy?

The answer is: True Christians(tm) follow the Holy Word of God ON ALL MATTERS, without exception.

The real question is, why don't you?

[zMuffinMan]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Yet you didn't answer my hypothetical question because it's silly and impossible. That is the same reason I am not answering your question.

Read Deuteronomy 22 Your answer is in there.

Ok, well hypothetically if i were to climb on a ladder to the moon i would not snack on the "green cheese" since there is no such thing as green cheese on the moon. But let us even say hypothetically there was green cheese on the moon, i would not eat it.

I suggest you get an education and learn what the word hypothetically actually means and how it is used. I also suggest you stop dodging the question and just answer the hypothetical question i put forward.

It most certainly is possible, women get raped all the time. Your daughter could possibly be raped, it is a possibility. It is not impossible. So stop acting like it could never ever ever happen.

[Malaysia_Christian]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Ok, well hypothetically if i were to climb on a ladder to the moon i would not snack on the "green cheese" since there is no such thing as green cheese on the moon. But let us even say hypothetically there was green cheese on the moon, i would not eat it.

I suggest you get an education and learn what the word hypothetically actually means and how it is used. I also suggest you stop dodging the question and just answer the hypothetical question i put forward.

It most certainly is possible, women get raped all the time. Your daughter could possibly be raped, it is a possibility. It is not impossible. So stop acting like it could never ever ever happen.

How about your daughter? or your mother?

Will you said you are the biproduct of your mother being raped by your father, legally by law of marraige?

[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

Ok, well hypothetically if i were to climb on a ladder to the moon i would not snack on the "green cheese" since there is no such thing as green cheese on the moon. But let us even say hypothetically there was green cheese on the moon, i would not eat it.

I suggest you get an education and learn what the word hypothetically actually means and how it is used. I also suggest you stop dodging the question and just answer the hypothetical question i put forward.

It most certainly is possible, women get raped all the time. Your daughter could possibly be raped, it is a possibility. It is not impossible. So stop acting like it could never ever ever happen.

If I was dodging your hypothetical question I would say my daughter couldn't get raped, because I don't have a daughter. I gave you my answer, or are you so filled with Satan that you can't even look at a link to the KJV Bible?

I'm really starting to get concerned about your obsession with rape though. Maybe you should turn yourself into the authorities before you do anything rash.

[zMuffinMan]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

If I was dodging your hypothetical question I would say my daughter couldn't get raped, because I don't have a daughter. I gave you my answer, or are you so filled with Satan that you can't even look at a link to the KJV Bible?

It still very clear you have little to no understanding of what the word hypothetical means and how it is applied. You have a round about answer in the form of "go read this Bible passage".

I want you to actually type it, to actually admit that if you, hypothetically speaking, had a daughter, and she, hypothetically speaking, was raped by me...Would you allow her to marry me if i paid you 50 shekels of silver worth? Remember this is a hypothetical question. If you are unsure of what the word means, by all means.. LOOK IT UP!

[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

It still very clear you have little to no understanding of what the word hypothetical means and how it is applied. You have a round about answer in the form of "go read this Bible passage".

I want you to actually type it, to actually admit that if you, hypothetically speaking, had a daughter, and she, hypothetically speaking, was raped by me...Would you allow her to marry me if i paid you 50 shekels of silver worth? Remember this is a hypothetical question. If you are unsure of what the word means, by all means.. LOOK IT UP!

No

[zMuffinMan]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

No

So you admittedly would not allow her to marry me? Which is going against what the Bible says and what others have agreed the Bible says.

What does the opening poster, revrggreen, and any "true christian" on these forums have to say about this?

What would your answers be given the same hypothetical question?

It would be a very simple answer for me, i would immediately disregard whatever any holy book teaches and base my actions on my own morals and values. I would certainly not let a man who raped my daughter marry her.

But for those that claim to be "true christians" on these forums, how do you go against your own thoughts and feelings? What do you do in such a conflict between what the Bible says, what your faith is apparently telling you to do and what your conscience is telling you?

[Seth Campbell]

Re: DEUTERONOMY 22:28 If a woman is raped, she MUST marry her rap

So you admittedly would not allow her to marry me? Which is going against what the Bible says and what others have agreed the Bible says.

What does the opening poster, revrggreen, and any "true christian" on these forums have to say about this?

What would your answers be given the same hypothetical question?

It would be a very simple answer for me, i would immediately disregard whatever any holy book teaches and base my actions on my own morals and values. I would certainly not let a man who raped my daughter marry her.

But for those that claim to be "true christians" on these forums, how do you go against your own thoughts and feelings? What do you do in such a conflict between what the Bible says, what your faith is apparently telling you to do and what your conscience is telling you?

No, I'm not going to write it out for you. You have the Biblical text.

You may want to look beside my name, I'm another one of those Evil True Christians(TM) No we do not disregard anything the Bible says because we don't like it. Doing that is a one way ticket to hell.

But if that's where you want to spend eternity, go right ahead