Hello, I know it's not a place for debate but I would want the opinions of religious people about it :
I just don't understand why it's an issue in this world, I mean where the whole concept come from except some books and traditions ? would we even had the concept of religion without it ? I mean i wasn't raised religiously (without being raised as an atheist, religion was just not a thing in my education and the best description of my parents about it would be "apatheists", if I was baptized roman catholic because it's what everyone do where I live ) and I would never think about things like religion and god(s) by my own, so it don't seems really natural to me (I know that many religious people thinks being religious is natural but from my experience, it's not the case)
I describe myself as atheist because I think that agnosticism is too much...passive : i don't consider "believe in god" and "don't believe in god" as two equals possibilities since for me, it's to those who affirms something to prove it more than those who don't believe in this thing; and I don't think It's really possible to be apatheist in a so religious world.
I have nothing about religious people but I don't understand them : how it's possible to believe so strongly in something without proofs.
And how you know it's the right religion ? I mean..well when someone ask about it generaly he is answered by an citation of the Bible that said "Jesus is the true path" or something like that but without offense, it's a bit senseless for someone who don't already believe in the Bible and Jesus and you're far the only ones to think like that : muslims said Islam is the true religion because it's written in the Quran, Jews thinks they are the chosen people because its written in the Tora, ect...why i would believe you rather than them ? Why i would believe them rather than you ?
Some others speak about religious experience but it exist in all religions and many good people die without this kind of experience and says "if someone is a good-will man, he will find God" is quite an unprobable and easy answer. (I doubt that NEVER a good-will man is dead before find God, by principle we can assume anyone can die at every time; and it's too easy to affirm that those who fails to see the Truth were not honest enough)
Some others said that the Truth must be not so much evident otherwise there is not free-will and the good choice must be more difficult to take than the bad ones but there is a difference between that and makes it completly unknowledgeable and so random (if you can't know what is the good choice, it's not really free-will and more of a gage)
And the most weird thing is that what is your religion is in 99% of the cases just a demographic thing (see statistic : there is religious map of the world) : most people believe in what they have been raised and in most places in the world, your religion is not even a choice.
And have you already seen someone's who wasn't raised with any idea of God becomes religious ? All converts I know had deep roted idea of the Christian God and were almost christians in denial.
I don't grasp how a "true" unbeliever can convert and why.
And if a religion is true does it means 99% of those who believe in this Religion goes in the Heavens because they have been raised in the good religion even if they wouldn't even considerate the "good religion" if they have been raised in an another religion ?
And 99% of those who believed in a wrong religion goes to hell because they have been raised in a wrong one even if they weren't less goods or open-minded than those who have been raised in the good religion ?
I don't think I'm closed-minded : I have reconsiderate my position several times, try to understand believers and all that; I don't think I'm smarter than most people so I'm a bit puzzled about the fact of being in a extrem minority in a world where almost everyone don't thinks at all like me but it's still the same problem.
I hope I was not offensing; if you have an opinion about it, it would be great.
Thanks. (Sorry for the bad english, it's not my native language)
I just don't understand why it's an issue in this world, I mean where the whole concept come from except some books and traditions ? would we even had the concept of religion without it ? I mean i wasn't raised religiously (without being raised as an atheist, religion was just not a thing in my education and the best description of my parents about it would be "apatheists", if I was baptized roman catholic because it's what everyone do where I live ) and I would never think about things like religion and god(s) by my own, so it don't seems really natural to me (I know that many religious people thinks being religious is natural but from my experience, it's not the case)
I describe myself as atheist because I think that agnosticism is too much...passive : i don't consider "believe in god" and "don't believe in god" as two equals possibilities since for me, it's to those who affirms something to prove it more than those who don't believe in this thing; and I don't think It's really possible to be apatheist in a so religious world.
I have nothing about religious people but I don't understand them : how it's possible to believe so strongly in something without proofs.
And how you know it's the right religion ? I mean..well when someone ask about it generaly he is answered by an citation of the Bible that said "Jesus is the true path" or something like that but without offense, it's a bit senseless for someone who don't already believe in the Bible and Jesus and you're far the only ones to think like that : muslims said Islam is the true religion because it's written in the Quran, Jews thinks they are the chosen people because its written in the Tora, ect...why i would believe you rather than them ? Why i would believe them rather than you ?
Some others speak about religious experience but it exist in all religions and many good people die without this kind of experience and says "if someone is a good-will man, he will find God" is quite an unprobable and easy answer. (I doubt that NEVER a good-will man is dead before find God, by principle we can assume anyone can die at every time; and it's too easy to affirm that those who fails to see the Truth were not honest enough)
Some others said that the Truth must be not so much evident otherwise there is not free-will and the good choice must be more difficult to take than the bad ones but there is a difference between that and makes it completly unknowledgeable and so random (if you can't know what is the good choice, it's not really free-will and more of a gage)
And the most weird thing is that what is your religion is in 99% of the cases just a demographic thing (see statistic : there is religious map of the world) : most people believe in what they have been raised and in most places in the world, your religion is not even a choice.
And have you already seen someone's who wasn't raised with any idea of God becomes religious ? All converts I know had deep roted idea of the Christian God and were almost christians in denial.
I don't grasp how a "true" unbeliever can convert and why.
And if a religion is true does it means 99% of those who believe in this Religion goes in the Heavens because they have been raised in the good religion even if they wouldn't even considerate the "good religion" if they have been raised in an another religion ?
And 99% of those who believed in a wrong religion goes to hell because they have been raised in a wrong one even if they weren't less goods or open-minded than those who have been raised in the good religion ?
I don't think I'm closed-minded : I have reconsiderate my position several times, try to understand believers and all that; I don't think I'm smarter than most people so I'm a bit puzzled about the fact of being in a extrem minority in a world where almost everyone don't thinks at all like me but it's still the same problem.
I hope I was not offensing; if you have an opinion about it, it would be great.
Thanks. (Sorry for the bad english, it's not my native language)







Comment